5. Toast two loaves of bread in the toaster oven or regular oven.
You can add butter to the toast when you toast it, if you decide to toast it in the oven. Reheat the chicken and dumplings until it’s hot. While the bread is toasting, cup up some lettuce and slice some tomatoes. Make sure you wash the lettuce and tomato thoroughly before placing on the sandwich.
Once the bread is toasted, spread some butter on both slices. The butter should melt fast, but if not don’t worry, it will eventually. Afterward, place a spoonful of chicken and dumplings on one slice of toasted bread. Add a piece of lettuce and slice of tomato on one piece of the toasted bread. Add mayonnaise or mustard on the other piece of toasted bread and place on top of the sandwich. It is best to enjoy this sandwich while it’s hot.